Warrior Ancient and Medieval Rules

[Tom McMillan]

In a message dated 7/26/01 7:04:50 AM, WarriorRules@yahoogroups.com writes:

<< they will be Irr D transport elements without other 'guard

figures' when the rules are published. Scott was concerned too many people

had never fought against transport and didn't get it. Well, they are gonna

hafta. >>

As an interested outsider, i think that this articulates a signifigant
problem. There does seem to be a prevailing philosophy of ' There may be some
concerns that a large proportion of players will find this section very
difficult to understand. Not our problem, they will just have to learn.'
That sort of presentation does run the risk of driving away many
potentially interested players.

[joncleaves]

I'm sorry, perhaps I missspoke.

What the colonel meant to say was: I am aware that some players of 7th have not
fought Transport elements before, for whatever reason. But that is not
sufficient reason to write an entirely new rule.

I am not aware that fighting versus transport is 'difficult'. Is there a
problem I am not aware of?

[Rob Turnball]

Greetings All
I wanted to follow up on a great Historicon. I have heard a lot of people
writing off the warrior rules etc, but they are more clear and secondly, in 9
battles I only had one major disagreement on the rules, where Scott put me
right, and I had left my ruleset at home. So the players and the game are
flexible enough that someone can play 9 games without the rule set and play
belivebly and well. I think this ruleset is very positive, and like every
other ruleset, can be subverted by cheats, however the rules are clear and
the game is very playable.
Thanks to all my opponents at Historicon for a great, relatively disagreement
free weekend. And people who look at discussions on this e-group as
indications of poor sportsmanship, should look at the tournaments and
conevntions for a fun gaming set.
Robert Turnbull

[Eric Turner]

Here, Here. Could not agree more.

Eric Turner

lilroblis@... wrote:

> Greetings All
> I wanted to follow up on a great Historicon. I have heard a lot of
> people
> writing off the warrior rules etc, but they are more clear and
> secondly, in 9
> battles I only had one major disagreement on the rules, where Scott
> put me
> right, and I had left my ruleset at home. So the players and the game
> are
> flexible enough that someone can play 9 games without the rule set and
> play
> belivebly and well. I think this ruleset is very positive, and like
> every
> other ruleset, can be subverted by cheats, however the rules are clear
> and
> the game is very playable.
> Thanks to all my opponents at Historicon for a great, relatively
> disagreement
> free weekend. And people who look at discussions on this e-group as
> indications of poor sportsmanship, should look at the tournaments and
> conevntions for a fun gaming set.
> Robert Turnbull
>
> Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
ADVERTISEMENT
[Lose 20 lbs by September 24th!]

>
> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
> WarriorRules-unsubscribe@egroups.com
>
>
>
> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.

[Kelly Wilkinson]

Hello All,
Strangely enough, I find myself agreeing with my
friend Robert! Each and every Warrior Game I had at
Historicon was very enjoyable! I applaud Jon for his
efforts to organize and his attempts to clarify the
rules set I have come to love over the years! My
theory is that most of the whiners have left Warrior
(7th ed.) and moved over to other sets. If you find
this set too much of a challenge, it's a free country,
do something else.
On another note, I sat near Robert and one of his
rounds and I noticed that he "really" was having a
good time crushing his opponent!

Kelly
"Deep down Jon, You Know I'm the MASTER"
--- lilroblis@... wrote:
> Greetings All
> I wanted to follow up on a great Historicon. I have
> heard a lot of people
> writing off the warrior rules etc, but they are more
> clear and secondly, in 9
> battles I only had one major disagreement on the
> rules, where Scott put me
> right, and I had left my ruleset at home. So the
> players and the game are
> flexible enough that someone can play 9 games
> without the rule set and play
> belivebly and well. I think this ruleset is very
> positive, and like every
> other ruleset, can be subverted by cheats, however
> the rules are clear and
> the game is very playable.
> Thanks to all my opponents at Historicon for a
> great, relatively disagreement
> free weekend. And people who look at discussions on
> this e-group as
> indications of poor sportsmanship, should look at
> the tournaments and
> conevntions for a fun gaming set.
> Robert Turnbull
>


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/

[Chris Bump]

Kelly,

Your comment about leaving is obvious and doesn't need to be expresed. As I
understand this, part of the genesis of FHM and Warrior as opposed to 7th was
to bring more folks back into the fold and grow the rule set, not to have it
die with those of us who currently play it and enjoy it enough not to leave.

Chris

[Kelly Wilkinson]

Chris,
What are you talking about!? Who said anything
about leaving!!!?? I have absolutely no clue as to
where this came from! How did you come to this
conclusion? I've not written any email that would
suggest that! Get your facts straight!
Kelly
--- cncbump@... wrote:
> Kelly,
>
> Your comment about leaving is obvious and doesn't
> need to be expresed. As I
> understand this, part of the genesis of FHM and
> Warrior as opposed to 7th was
> to bring more folks back into the fold and grow the
> rule set, not to have it
> die with those of us who currently play it and enjoy
> it enough not to leave.
>
> Chris
>


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/

I agree,as much as it pains me, with Kelly to the point that the rules are
much more organized and comprehensive than in the past. Jon has done
tremendous work and brought be back from the depths of DBM. Oh and Kelly I
have CRUSHED YOU the last two times.
Mark

-----Original Message-----
From: kelly wilkinson [mailto:jwilkinson62@...]
Sent: Sunday, July 29, 2001 3:27 AM
To: WarriorRules@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [WarriorRules] Digest Number 300


Hello All,
Strangely enough, I find myself agreeing with my
friend Robert! Each and every Warrior Game I had at
Historicon was very enjoyable! I applaud Jon for his
efforts to organize and his attempts to clarify the
rules set I have come to love over the years! My
theory is that most of the whiners have left Warrior
(7th ed.) and moved over to other sets. If you find
this set too much of a challenge, it's a free country,
do something else.
On another note, I sat near Robert and one of his
rounds and I noticed that he "really" was having a
good time crushing his opponent!

Kelly
"Deep down Jon, You Know I'm the MASTER"
--- lilroblis@... wrote:
> Greetings All
> I wanted to follow up on a great Historicon. I have
> heard a lot of people
> writing off the warrior rules etc, but they are more
> clear and secondly, in 9
> battles I only had one major disagreement on the
> rules, where Scott put me
> right, and I had left my ruleset at home. So the
> players and the game are
> flexible enough that someone can play 9 games
> without the rule set and play
> belivebly and well. I think this ruleset is very
> positive, and like every
> other ruleset, can be subverted by cheats, however
> the rules are clear and
> the game is very playable.
> Thanks to all my opponents at Historicon for a
> great, relatively disagreement
> free weekend. And people who look at discussions on
> this e-group as
> indications of poor sportsmanship, should look at
> the tournaments and
> conevntions for a fun gaming set.
> Robert Turnbull
>


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/


To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
WarriorRules-unsubscribe@egroups.com



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

[Kelly Wilkinson]

And?. . . . .

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/

[Kelly Wilkinson]

Mark The Mighty Conqueror,

. . . And they were both "Spankings" that shall
not be forgotten for centuries to come in the great
history of "Warrior!"

Kelly
"The Vanquished"

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/