| John Murphy Legate
 
  
 
 Joined: 12 Apr 2006
 Posts: 1625
 
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Mon Aug 16, 2004 4:10 am    Post subject: TACTICS/RULES lancers facing li in front of mass-shooter foo |  |  
				| 
 |  
				| My understanding of the rules is that troops which are
 interpenetrated are unable to shoot in the same phase.
 
 So LI evading lancers or routing from them through massed 4/stand
 shooters (a legal interpenetration hence one they would not or could
 not avoid) would cause those troops to be unable to support shoot
 when the lancers hit them (converted charge, pursuit or simply a
 charge against a new target). Furthermore it is likely if the
 lancers charged impetuously that they would still be considered
 impetuous when they hit or pursue into the uncovered massed shooter
 target.
 
 On the other hand, depending on circumstances the shooters, if loose
 order, may get to avoid a waver test this way, right? If the contact
 happens as a result of the LI evading through during a charge
 response _then_ I think the loose order would have to test, would
 not get to support shoot, and would be in the worst shape against
 impetuous charging lancers counting L factors. If it happened as a
 result of pursuing routing LI then it is a pursuit so no charge
 responses meaning no waver test, and no L factors although the
 lancers would get 1.5 ranks and probably still impetuous.
 
 So my question is - is this a real bad idea for mounted to use enemy
 LI as a shield against the massed shooters behind them?
 
 Of course, maybe there are better ways to do this! But given a lot
 of support shooters that you are having trouble closing with and not
 the best tactical situation maybe this is not a bad way to avoid
 being support shot down 6 or something horrible like that?
 
 Comments, suggestions? Especially do I have something missing with
 the rules in this?
 
 
 |  |