Don Coon Imperator

Joined: 12 Apr 2006 Posts: 2742
|
Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2001 1:39 am Post subject: July 15 draft comments pg 51-58 |
 |
|
8.11 "(x.xx)" should be "(6.13)"
8.3 2nd bullet add "element" between "shooters" and "or to"
8.5 add "this element does not even have to to be there. In effect this
makes each element have a 3 element wide shooting arc" to the end of the
first sentance.
8.5 "(12.4)" should be "(6.53)"
8.5 2nd bullet. This bullet makes no sense. The bullets are for "units
that may shoot all around" A single bolt shooter on a cart can not be a
unit, as a unit must have at least 2 elements in it per 2.52.
8.51 add this whole para. "To be able to shoot at an enemy, the enemy must
be visible to each shooting element (or to an element of their own body
directly in front of them). For a target body to count as visible, a line
must be drawn from each front corner of the shooting element to any point on
the target body. The 2 lines do not have to be drawn to the same point on
the target body. If either of these lines is interupted by LOS blocking
bodies or terrain, the element may not shoot at that target body."
8.6 3rd para "(x.xx)" should be ???
8.7 6th para after the bullet list "even it to" should be "even if to"
8.83. This para is very clear if your intent was to let any body in HTH
from a previous bound to be a legal target for support shooting with no
other restrictions. We have always thought the provisions of 8.82 applied
in subsequent bounds of HTH, but 8.83 clearly does not have any
restrictions. Is that the intent? I do recommend a reword to the first
sentance to "bodies already in HTH contact from the previous bound can only
shoot..."
8.93 second deduct 1 item reword to "If the target is at higher elevation"
9.43 add the following after the first sentance "If a mixed morale body is
fighting, the random factor is adjusted for each fighting element. So a
single body may have multiple random factors in a combat. EX: Front rank
IRR A, and second rank IRR C, all troops armed with JLS. A red 3 and Green
4 would yield +3 for the front rank, and +1 for the back rank."
If I have this wrong you still need a statement about how to handle mixed
morale bodies. The above is how we play it.
9.43 2nd para add "any" between "other "A" or" and ""B" class reduce".
Without the "any, the word other crosses the "or" or makes the "B" reference
unclear. It could be read as just REG B.
Same para add "IRR A" between ""D"" and "and "E" class"
You need the IRR A reference to make the statement complete.
9.61 1st bullet reword to "The target is at higher eleveation"
9.61 Add "(8.51)" between "must be visible" and "the shooter".
Thats it through page 58. More later.
Don
|
|